Discover the BEST Pizza in the PHX East Valley!!

Welcome to the culinary haven of PHX East Valley, where pizza lovers are in for a treat! Whether you’re a fan of classic Margherita or crave inventive toppings, we’ve got you covered. In this blog post, we’ll introduce you to some of the finest pizza establishments in the area. Each one offers a unique pizza experience that’s sure to satisfy your cravings. Let’s embark on a pizza adventure like no other!

Pizza is a beloved dish around the world, but in the United States, two distinct styles reign supreme: New York Style and Chicago Style. These pizza styles couldn’t be more different, and they both have legions of passionate fans.  To summarize:

New York Style Pizza:

  • Thin, foldable slices.
  • Thin, crisp crust.
  • Toppings are minimal, often just tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
  • Sauce is placed on top of the cheese.
  • Uses part-skim, low-moisture mozzarella cheese.
  • Perfect for on-the-go, quick bites.

 

Chicago Style Pizza:

  • Deep, thick, and buttery crust, more like a pie.
  • Toppings are piled high with layers of mozzarella, ingredients, and chunky tomato sauce.
  • Sauce is placed at the bottom, atop the crust.
  • Uses whole milk mozzarella, resulting in a melty, cheesy consistency.
  • A hearty, knife-and-fork dining experience, not suited for quick bites.

NY Style Pizza Restaurants

Sals Gilbert Pizza-Nestled in the heart of Gilbert, Sal’s Gilbert Pizza serves up New York-style pizza that’s as authentic as it gets. With its thin, foldable slices and a wide range of toppings, Sal’s is the place to go for an East Coast pizza experience.  Definitely a FAV!

Brooklyn Vs Pizza-4 locations! Brooklyn V’s Pizza brings the taste of the Big Apple to the East Valley with not one, but four locations! Enjoy their handcrafted, wood-fired pizzas with a variety of fresh and unique toppings. It’s a slice of New York right here in Arizona.

Fire and Brimstone Eatery. Fire and Brimstone Eatery takes pizza to a whole new level with their wood-fired, artisanal creations. Their commitment to using quality, local ingredients results in flavors that are nothing short of spectacular.

Venezia’s Pizzeria-If you’re in search of classic New York-style pizza with a variety of toppings, Venezia’s Pizzeria is the place to be. Their dedication to quality and consistency has made them a beloved choice for locals- including a few of us at Coveted Spaces AZ!

Craft 64– Craft 64 is a pizzeria that takes pride in using the finest ingredients to craft their pizzas. With a focus on locally sourced, organic ingredients and an extensive craft beer selection, it’s a must-visit for pizza connoisseurs.

Myke ‘s pizza-  Myke’s Pizza is where traditional Italian meets modern flair. A TOP FAV for locals, their menu offers a delectable selection of pizzas, from classic to inventive. Don’t forget to try their signature creations for a memorable experience.  

Grimaldi’sGrimaldi’s is a name that resonates with pizza lovers, known for their coal-brick oven pies. With a perfect blend of mozzarella, basil, and plum tomatoes, their pizzas capture the essence of authentic New York pizza.  Is you mouth watering yet?

Buono’s is all about capturing the essence of Italian cuisine, and their pizzas are no exception. With a focus on fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, it’s the ideal spot for those craving a taste of Italy.

Geno’s giant slice– 2 locations!  Geno’s Giant Slice offers oversized GINORMOUS, delicious pizzas that are perfect for sharing. With two locations in the East Valley, they’re a go-to destination for a hearty pizza experience.  Also the best pizza to impress kids and teenagers with their huge slices, all while being budget friendly!

Bucca Di Bepo.  For a family-friendly (and favorite) dining experience, head to Bucca Di Beppo. Their menu boasts a variety of Italian dishes, including mouthwatering pizzas with generous portions perfect for sharing.  

Oreganos is more than a pizzeria; it’s an Arizona institution. With their unique, eclectic atmosphere and a menu featuring Chicago-style and thin-crust pizzas, Oregano’s offers an unforgettable dining experience with many delicious options for every tastebud!

Sourdough Pizza Italian Restaurant is a HIDDEN gem in East Mesa, where the love for sourdough meets Italian flavors. Their creative pizzas and warm atmosphere make it a delightful spot for pizza aficionados.  This joint has been around since we were kids and they still offer the same amazing flavor we grew up with!

Chicago Style Pizza Restaurants

Spinato’s Pizzeria– 6 locations.  Spinato’s Pizzeria is famous for its Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas. Dive into layers of cheesy goodness in this culinary tribute to the Windy City.

Crave Pizzeria crafts Chicago-style pizza with a twist. Their inventive toppings and impeccable execution make for a memorable dining experience.

Vero Chicago Pizza– Vero Chicago Pizza brings the authentic taste of Chicago to the East Valley. Indulge in their deep-dish pies, filled with rich, savory flavors.

Vito’s Pizza & Italian Ristorante is known for its mouthwatering Chicago-style pizza, offering a hearty and satisfying dining experience.

Lou Malnati’s– 8 locations.  Lou Malnati’s is a Chicago legend, and their East Valley location upholds the tradition of deep-dish pizza that’s second to none.

Salerno’s Restaurant & Pizzeria offers a taste of the Windy City with their Chicago-style pizza. Dive into a sea of cheese and toppings that redefine pizza indulgence.

Barros Pizza has been a staple in the East Valley for years, known for their thin-crust pizzas and extensive topping choices. It’s a perfect place to savor a slice of pizza perfection with the family, all while being a bit more budget friendly!  Pro tip- This is my go to Friday night pizza place for the kids…

There’s no right or wrong answer when it comes to New York style vs. Chicago style pizza. It all boils down to personal preference, and quite possibly your taste buds at the moment!  Can you really go wrong with marinara, cheese and bread?? New York-style pizza is perfect for those who crave a quick, satisfying slice that’s easy to eat on the go. Chicago-style pizza, on the other hand, is a comforting and indulgent meal that requires a bit more time and a hearty appetite. Whichever you choose, one thing is certain: both styles offer a slice of pizza perfection in their own unique way.

So, the next time you find yourself in a pizza debate, remember that it’s all about celebrating the diversity of flavors and styles that make pizza one of the world’s most beloved dishes. Enjoy your pizza journey!

Did we miss your favorite Pizza restaurant?

It's easy to do with so many options in the PHX East Valley! Click below to email me who your favorite Pizza is!

LET US KEEP YOU IN THE LOOP

Never miss a thing in the PHX East Valley!

Get a FREE list of fun, local events delivered to your inbox weekly!